Strong protection against thousands of threats

The lab evaluates each security app for Android in terms of its protection. In the test, it is required to detect, block and quarantine a veritable deluge of infected apps. In the real-time test, the lab uses totally freshly uncovered malware apps – nearly 3,000 samples. In addition, the experts subject the Android devices to an onslaught of an additional 3,300 malicious apps, which have already been wreaking havoc on the Web for up to 2 weeks, however.

The apps from Avast, AVG, Bitdefender, G DATA, NortonLifeLock and Trend Micro each fulfilled the detection exercise 100% in both test steps. This was followed by the apps from AhnLab, F-Secure, Kaspersky and McAfee, committing minor errors in one or both tests. All of the apps mentioned received the full 6 points in the test category of protection.

The apps from Avira, Ikarus, Protected.net and securiON achieved between 99.9 and 99.1 percent detection in both tests. They still received good scores of 5.5 points. Only Google Play Protect cannot compete with any other app when it comes to detection: only 85.2 for known threats and 61.6 percent for fresh malware. This accounted for zero points.

CPU and battery savers

Every Android protection app working in the background needs some processing power, battery power and data from the Internet. But just how much does each security app require? The lab examined these criteria as well and was able to give favorable ratings across the board. The use of the protection tools examined caused neither any excessive CPU load on the test devices, nor was much power required from the battery, and only little additional data was needed from the Internet in the background. For this economical use of system resources, all of the protection apps evaluated received the full 6 points.

Alarm in the system

Although many users only download their apps from trustworthy app stores, alarms occur repeatedly that an app is infected with malware. So they should not be installed! But it is really annoying when the whole thing is based on a false alarm. That is why the laboratory checks whether the security apps can also truly distinguish the good apps from the bad. In doing so, the lab sends over 2,500 harmless apps from the Google Play Store to the secured devices. In addition, the lab uses an additional 1,200 apps from other app stores for the friend-foe detection. The perfect result: no alarm, as all the apps are harmless. 13 of the 15 apps achieved optimal results here and were thus awarded the full 6 points. The Ikarus app committed only a minor error with a single app. An interesting result: Google Play Protect wrongly classifies 7 apps from its own store and 24 apps from other stores as threats.

A security app is a necessity

Security app deniers like to argue that the apps will only eat up their battery life, and probably wouldn't find any dangerous apps anyway. The latest test demonstrates just how wrong these statements are! First: none of the apps tested placed a load on the Android system or used large battery resources. 10 of the 15 apps evaluated achieved excellent protection results and were thus awarded the full 6 points. And because these candidates neither reported false alarms nor put a load on the system, the lab awarded them the full 6 points 3 times, i.e. 18 points. They are the apps from AhnLab, Avast, AVG, Bitdefender, F-Secure, G DATA, Kaspersky, McAfee, NortonLifeLock and Trend Micro. Some of the protection apps mentioned can even be used free of charge.

Those prepared to spend a bit of money on an app with an annual licensing fee will benefit from the apps' many extra features. Just what those entail, for example, can be found in the article "The Best Extra Features in Security Apps for Android – What They Have to Offer!”